Orientation

Comparing review platforms – how to recognise a fair model

Not every review comes into being the same way. This page explains the three basic models of review services, what the differences mean for consumers and businesses – and which questions you should ask any provider. It deliberately names no other provider: we describe model types, not other companies' services.

In short

The decisive difference is not the number of stars but the question: what must have happened before someone may write – and who checks it? TrustStar is a customer portal: what gets reviewed is an actual business transaction that the business can match and confirm. Contributions without that link are either not published or expressly labelled “Unconfirmed”. Experiences from advice or a shop visit without a purchase are published in a separate contact track with its own score – they do not distort the customer rating.

How to read this page. The columns “Open experience portal” and “Pure collection/widget service” describe model types in their typical form, not individual companies. Providers may implement individual points differently – their own guidelines and terms always prevail. Our own statements are substantiated by our review guidelines, the terms and the page Authenticity of customer reviews.

The three basic models

1. Open experience portal

Anyone can write about any business, even without an order – the platform lives on reach and a large database. That is valuable for market overview and for businesses that have never invited anyone. The price of the model: the link to a real transaction is often not provable, and checking usually happens after publication, when someone reports an entry.

2. Pure collection or widget service

The business collects reviews itself (form, e-mail campaign, QR code) and displays them on its own website. That is fast and inexpensive. Two questions are decisive: who sees incoming reviews first, and who decides what is published? If both rest with the business, selection by content can arise – deliberately or through the order of approval.

3. Customer portal with transaction confirmation (TrustStar)

What is reviewed is a business transaction. For contributions without a code the business initially sees them without stars and text and only answers whether the transaction took place or can be matched. Publication happens only afterwards – or after three working days with the label “Unconfirmed”. The business cannot select anything and cannot have anything deleted; removal happens only for breaches of the guidelines or the law, after our examination.

Model comparison

Criterion Open experience portal Pure collection/widget service TrustStar (customer portal)
Who may write? in principle anyone whoever the business invites whoever experienced the transaction themselves – also on behalf of someone or as a witness
Link to a real transaction typically not required by the model via the business's invitation required: code, confirmation or document check
Who sees stars and text first? the public the business nobody – stars and text stay hidden until confirmation
Release of positive contributions immediately by the business same deadline for praise and criticism (3 working days, Mon–Fri excluding holidays)
If the business does not react stays published typically no publication publication after the deadline, labelled “Unconfirmed”
Contact without purchase (advice, shop visit) counts like an order depends on the business's setup separate list, separate label, separate score – no effect on the customer rating
Removal at the business's request no, only for legal breaches typically possible no – only for breaches of guidelines or law, after our examination
Paid placement / better position sometimes advertising space not applicable (own website) no, in no plan
Google reviews in the profile depends on the provider depends on the provider only after the profile owner's release (OAuth), labelled separately, never in the TrustStar rating
Cost for consumers free free free and ad-free
Edit / withdraw your own review usually via an account depends on the provider yourself via a personal link: edit for 30 days, withdraw any time, add a note afterwards

“typically” = follows from the basic model and may be regulated differently in individual cases. As of 11 November 2026.

What TrustStar deliberately does not do

  • No authenticity guarantee. We check the link to the transaction, but reviews are created outside the platform. Misuse can never be entirely ruled out – we say so openly and label what is unchecked.
  • No star gate. We never ask for the rating first in order to forward only satisfied people.
  • No deletion on request. Not for paying customers either. Factual criticism stays.
  • No bought reviews, no reviews by employees or competitors – and no rewards for positive ratings.
  • No Google data without release. We do not read third-party Google profiles; without a connection we show only a link.
  • No promise of stars in Google search. We mark up our profile pages according to the rules; whether stars appear is decided by Google alone.
  • No automatic deletion by sentiment. Technical procedures flag anomalies; a human decides (Art. 14 DSA).

Eight questions to ask any provider

You can ask these questions of us and of any other provider. Anyone who answers them in writing makes their model verifiable:

  1. Must a real business transaction exist – and how is it evidenced?
  2. Does the business see stars and text before deciding on publication?
  3. Does the same deadline apply to positive and critical contributions?
  4. What happens if the business does not react – is it published, and how is that labelled?
  5. What exactly does the label “verified” mean – is a plausible account enough?
  6. Do contacts without a purchase count towards the same score as orders?
  7. Can the business have contributions removed, and who decides on reports?
  8. Where is it stated how authenticity is ensured – and is it linked directly next to the review list?

Our answers are on Authenticity of customer reviews, in the review guidelines and in the frequently asked questions.

For businesses: switching and running in parallel

  • No exclusivity. You can use TrustStar alongside other services; we require neither sole commitment nor a minimum number of reviews.
  • Bring existing reviews. Reviews you already collected can be imported – with a source note and labelled as imported, not as “verified”.
  • Invite without selection. Any customer may review after a transaction, not only the satisfied one. Invitations stay neutral, with no reward for good ratings.
  • Monthly cancellation, data portable. Paid plans can be cancelled monthly with effect at month end; the free basic profile remains if you wish, and your reviews and replies are not lost.
  • Google connection free of charge. Releasing your own Google profile is available in every plan – including Basic.
  • Authenticity notice included. Widget and profile link to the information page; for your own website there is a ready-made snippet to copy (section for businesses).

See the free basic profile How we check authenticity

Basis of this page

This page is a factual description of models without naming other providers and is not legal advice. For information about other services, please consult their own guidelines and terms. The German version is binding.